The delusion...

Value Investing

Other stuff

Showing posts with label Joel Greenblatt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Joel Greenblatt. Show all posts

Is there a little book that beats "The little book that beats the market"?

Recently, I looked at the little book that (still) beats the market.

Being a revised edition of the orignal (hence the "still" in the title), towards the end of the book, Greenblatt responds to suggestions for improvements to his magic formula.  Interestingly, he tried a number of these suggested improvements using his simulation tool, and despite sounding like good ideas, none of the suggestions actually improved the portfolio performance.

This reminded me of the classic iterated prisoner's dilemma competition, where the simple winner (tit-for-tat) of the first competition also won the second competition, despite all the new entrants in the second competition knowing exactly how it worked to win the first competition, and being written to specifically beat tit-for-tat.  Each of the so-called "improvements" on tit-for-tat could beat tit-for-tat, but couldn't outperform tit-for-tat on average against all of the other strategies.

So, I pose the question - can the magic formula be improved, or does it's elegant simplicity outperform any variation?

The little book that beats the market - still

I've just finished reading the little book that still beats the market, by Joel Greenblatt.  It's written in a very unique and quirky style that resonates well with me.  The magic formula that he documents is a value investing strategy worthy of review.  He very eloquently describes it as "systematically finding above-average companies at below average prices".

The essence of Grenblatt's magic formula is to rank each company by 2 criteria. The first criteria is "quality", for which he uses return on capital, and the second criteria is "cheapness", for which he uses earnings yield.  As point of detail, for return on capital he uses EBIT/(Net Working Capital + Net Fixed Assets), and for earnings yield he uses EBIT/Enterprise Value.